Why were human beings so fond of using circular shapes? Was this only for practical reasons, or could there have been other reasons too? What kinds of uses have human beings found for the circular shape?
Step-by-step solution
Idea: A good answer gives practical reasons, at least one non-practical reason, and a list of uses, and if possible backs one reason with a calculation.
- Practical reasons. (1) Easy to make: tie a rope to a peg and walk round. (2) A wheel or log rolls smoothly because every point of the rim is the same distance from the centre. (3) No corners, so pressure is spread evenly: clay pots, wells and domes are strong. (4) For a fixed length of wall, a circle encloses the largest area.1 mark
- A check of (4): 88 m of fence as a square (side 22 m) encloses 22 × 22 = 484 m2; as a circle (radius 14 m, since 2 × 227 × 14 = 88) it encloses 227 × 14 × 14 = 616 m2. Same fence, about 27% more space.1 mark
- Other reasons and uses. The circle is perfectly symmetric and looks complete; people saw it in the sun, the moon and ripples, and used it in art, mandalas and sacred buildings. Uses: wheels and carts, pottery, wells, round huts, granaries and cylindrical towers, coins, plates, bangles, clocks, gears and pulleys, round tables (everyone equally close to the centre), arenas and stadiums.1 mark
Answer to write in the exam
Practical: easy to draw (rope and peg); rolls; no corners (strong); largest area for a given perimeter.
Check: 88 m fence: square 22 × 22 = 484 m2; circle r = 14 m: 227 × 142 = 616 m2.
Other reasons: symmetry, beauty, sun and moon, cultural and religious meaning.
Uses: wheels, pots, wells, huts, granaries, coins, clocks, gears.
Common mistakes that cost marks
- Giving only one reason. The question asks for practical reasons, other reasons and uses.
- Claiming a circle has the largest perimeter for a given area. It is the other way: the smallest perimeter for a given area (largest area for a given perimeter).
How this can come in the exam
A gardener has 88 m of fencing. Which shape of enclosure gives the greatest area?
- A square
- A circle
- A 30 m × 14 m rectangle
- An equilateral triangle
Show answer
(B) A circle
Square: 484 m2; rectangle: 420 m2; circle (r = 14 m): 616 m2; triangle: about 373 m2. The circle wins.
Try one yourself
A rope 44 m long is laid out first as a square and then as a circle. Compare the areas enclosed. (Use π = 227.)
Show answer
Square: 11 × 11 = 121 m2. Circle: r = 7, area 154 m2. The circle encloses 33 m2 more.
More questions like this
- Such reasoning suggests that for a circle too, if C = circumference and A = area, the ratio C2 : A must be some fixed constant. But what is this constant?
- As the slices become smaller and smaller, the arcs in the figure (B) become more and more closer to a line. This makes the figure more and more closer to a parallelogram with base = half the circumference (why?) = πr, height = radius r.
- Find the area of a sector of a circle with radius 7 cm if the angle of the sector is 60°.
- Find the area of a quadrant of a circle whose circumference is 44 cm.
- The length of the minute hand of a clock is 7 cm. Find the area swept by the minute hand in 10 minutes.