Explain, using a real-world example of debt, why subtracting a negative number is the same as adding a positive number (e.g., 10 − (−5) = 15).
Step-by-step solution
Idea: A negative number is a debt. Subtracting means taking something away. Taking away a debt leaves you richer by the same amount, exactly as if you had been given that money.
- Suppose you hold ₹15 in cash but owe a friend ₹5. Your worth is 15 + (−5) = ₹10.½ mark
- Your friend cancels the debt: the debt of ₹5 is taken away. In symbols this is ‘subtract −5’: 10 − (−5).½ mark
- Now you hold ₹15 and owe nothing, so your worth is ₹15. It has gone up by ₹5, exactly as if someone had given you ₹5.½ mark
- So removing a debt of 5 has the same effect as adding 5: 10 − (−5) = 10 + 5 = 15.½ mark
Check: Number line: the gap from −5 up to 10 is 15 steps, and 10 − (−5) measures exactly that gap ✓.
Answer to write in the exam
Example: cash ₹15, debt ₹5 ⇒ worth = 15 + (−5) = ₹10
Debt of ₹5 cancelled ⇒ 10 − (−5)
New worth = ₹15 (cash ₹15, no debt) = 10 + 5
∴ 10 − (−5) = 10 + 5 = 15; removing a debt is the same as adding money.
Common mistakes that cost marks
- Writing 10 − (−5) = 5 by ignoring the second minus sign.
- Explaining with an example that adds a debt instead of removing one; adding a debt is 10 + (−5) = 5.
- Giving only the rule ‘two minuses make a plus’ with no real-world explanation, which the question asks for.
How this can come in the exam
−7 − (−12) =
- −19
- −5
- 5
- 19
Show answer
(C) 5
−7 − (−12) = −7 + 12 = 5.
Assertion (A): 8 − (−3) = 11.
Reason (R): Removing a debt of 3 increases one’s worth by 3.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true but R is false.
- A is false but R is true.
Show answer
(A) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
8 − (−3) = 8 + 3 = 11, and R is exactly why subtracting −3 is adding 3.
Try one yourself
Explain with a debt example why 20 − (−8) = 28.
Show answer
If a debt of ₹8 is cancelled, your worth rises by ₹8, as if you had been given ₹8: 20 − (−8) = 20 + 8 = 28.
More questions like this
- As society grew more complex, measuring became just as important as counting. If a farmer divides a field of wheat among his three children, how much does each get? If a recipe calls for half a cup of ghee, how do we represent that mathematically?
- Can you explain why we need q ≠ 0 in the definition of a rational number?
- 1. While adding or subtracting two rational numbers having different denominators, how will you make the denominators equal?
2. Verify the distributive law for rational numbers. - Prove that the following rational numbers are equal:
- Find the sum: